HST and Commercial Real Property TransactionsWednesday, June 19, 2019
Harmonized sales tax (“HST”) of 13% is imposed upon every taxable supply (i.e., sale) of property or services in Ontario, including commercial real estate.
For commercial real estate, an exception1 applies where a party making a taxable supply of commercial real property is not required to collect HST so long as the purchaser is an HST registrant. The registrant purchaser is responsible for assessing and directly remitting the HST on the acquisition to the Canada Revenue Agency. The purchaser then typically claims input tax credits (“ITCs”) to offset the HST payable and will not be required to remit amounts for HST.
Standard practice in the sale of commercial real property is for a vendor to obtain a certificate from the purchaser confirming that it is acquiring the property on its own behalf. The purchaser will also provide warranties with respect to registrant status, self-assessment, tax remittance, and applicable indemnities.
Classes of Real Property & Specific Transactions
The application of HST to real property transactions can be complex and highly fact-specific. There can be considerably different results depending on the nature of the property as well as its previous ownership and use. This complexity is particularly applicable to transactions involving new or substantially renovated residential and multi-residential property, and conversions between commercial and residential uses.
The purchase of a ‘residential complex’, being a multi-residential property that is not constructed by the vendor, is generally an ‘exempt supply’ and therefore not subject to HST. This is relevant for mixed-use properties, where the portion of the property containing residential units is deemed to be a residential complex for the purposes of computing HST and claiming ITCs. Suppliers engaged in making exempt supplies are generally not eligible to claim ITCs.
The purchase of vacant undeveloped land (including farmland) is typically treated the same as any other supply of commercial real property. However, the acquisition of vacant land may be exempt from HST in certain situations, such as personal use recreational property or lands acquired from charitable organizations. These exemptions are very fact specific as there are often narrow distinctions between farmland, used residential property and personal use recreational property.
With respect to commercial leases, landlords must collect and remit HST on all rents (including operating costs and realty taxes) and are generally entitled to claim ITCs for all HST paid on expenditures in their commercial activities.
HST: Practical Considerations for Commercial Vendors/Purchasers
As the consequences of HST non-compliance can be sizeable in the form of payment of 13% of the value of the subject transaction, it is recommended that both purchasers and vendors take precautions to protect themselves from potential liability.
For a Vendor:
- ensure that the party signing the purchase agreement also receives the taxable supply by taking beneficial ownership and is an HST registrant2;
- when the purchase agreement is being assigned by the purchaser, ensure that the agreement is assigned to the recipient of the conveyance of the beneficial interest rather than the nominee/trustee; and
- obtain indemnities from the purchaser against HST, penalties, costs and/or interest relating to any failure by the purchaser to comply with HST registrant status, self-assessment and tax remittance.
For a Purchaser:
- if intending to claim ITCs, ensure that the purchaser entity is an HST registrant as of the date the supply is made (i.e., the ‘closing date’) otherwise the ITC claim will be denied;
- when using a title nominee, assign the purchase agreement to the party that takes beneficial title rather than registered title;
- incur costs in the name of the purchaser entity so as not to jeopardize the entitlement to ITCs;
- for transactions where HST applicability is uncertain (e.g., residential or vacant lands), ensure that the purchase agreement provides that HST is to be ‘included in’ the purchase price; and
- in transactions involving joint ventures, ensure compliance with the ‘operator’ rules and the required election under Section 273 of the ETA.
The application of HST to real property transactions is highly technical and fact specific. Expert advice is strongly recommended for all transactions involving any unique features, changes in property use or multiple parties.
If you have any questions with respect to the matters discussed above, please contact Jonathan Born at email@example.com, Marija Tasevska at firstname.lastname@example.org, or any other member of our Commercial Real Estate or Tax practice groups.
This update is intended as a summary only and should not be regarded or relied upon as advice to any specific client or regarding any specific situation.
If you would like further information regarding the issues discussed in this update or if you wish to discuss any aspect of this commentary, please feel free to contact us.
1 See subsection 221(2)(b) of the Excise Tax Act (the “ETA”)
2 The Canada Revenue Agency’s GST/HST Online Web Registry allows parties to verify an HST registrant’s status as of a specified date.